On one
hand you could probably call 2 States
better than most of Chetan Bhagat based movies, because it has a nifty concept.
On the other (more accurate) hand you could probably call 2 States worse than most of Bhagat’s flicks, because it takes such
a potentially clever concept and does nothing with it but involve stereotype
jokes, lame romance, and really limp melodrama.
As Kai Po Che proved, in the hands of a talented
filmmaker 2 States could have been a classic
little rom com drama. With diretor Abhishek Verman the 2 States we've been presented with feels like a fairly fun rom com
drama that's been overtaken by uninspired acting, generic plotting, overlong
running time and a lethargic pace.
The
plot is precisely what you expect, point by isolated point – guy and girl
(Arjun and Alia) meet at IIM-A, fall in both lust and love, are trying to get
married, and face a Herculean task because they’re from .. 2 different states.
It’s an interesting concept for a comedy but unfortunately it’s all premise and
no plot. We get some puppy-love romance, a handful of scenes which showcase the
modern free spirited sexually liberated desi youth, one dozen music montages
that give a respite from the banal exchanges between the leads and an unapologetically
happy ending to keep the target audience appeased.
This
is supposed to be a feel good family entertainer, and on that front 2 States is targeted towards its
audience with an ultra precision sniper. There’s plenty of dynamics between
South vs North India, and daddy issues to keep the target audience on their
tenterhooks. There is a ton of ladai-jhagda between the in-laws to pander to
the cultural mismatch between Chennai and Delhi. But the observations are
clichéd and simplistic, and there’s a paper-thin superficiality throughout
which makes the film a Swiss cheese layer.
There
are key scenes where the guy impresses the girl’s parents, and vice versa. And
there are key scenes where the cultural gaffes of both the South and North,
like general pretentiousness and dowry are established. The latter is when you notice
the slipshod tonal shifts that Verman employs while desperately aiming to pad
the screenplay with every cliché under the sun. Thanks to the tonal shifts 2 States goes from light romance to simplistic
social issue pandering with no consistency. We never really get to see the
defining moments of the guy and the girl’s blossoming romance, which is both
odd and silly because we never really care for them to remain together. Content
detailing their love for one another is shown in music-montages, yet huge
chunks of running time are dedicated to emotional wrangling.
It
is also jarring to see the film dabble in broad, obvious, and unflattering
caricatures of its characters. I'm not saying Delhi-ites and Madrasis have no
sense of humour, but if you're going to bomb us with stereotypes it's probably
better to do so with some creativity or wit. Banana leaf and Punjabi daroo
offer a few stray giggles but 2 States
never comes close to being creative or witty. It's just a goofy impersonation
of both cultures, not a classy roast of them. We’re also meant to take the
melodrama as sincere and effective, but it just comes across as manipulative. So
the equation is this - spend one hour mildly chuckling as limp campus romance between
Arjun and Alia is paraded, and then spend the other one and a half hour getting
weepy-eyed as Arjun and Alia try to turn a hallmark greeting card into
something with actual heart and soul.
And
the actors certainly don't help matters. Aside from Alia’s occasionally fiery
performance there's the virtually complete ineptitude of Arjun Kapoor’s puppy
faced good guy shtick. The bloke just doesn’t emote in any scene, and can
neither pull off the charming lover nor the frustrated punching bag stuck
between both sides. Alia’s role here is not as well defined as in Highway, and her performance clearly shows
that she’s a director’s actor. She does the occasional South twang, thankfully
without overdramatizing it, but spends most of the film doing a cutesy smile.
She does the cutesy smile even in a scene where her fiancé tells her the
biggest emotional conflict of his life. Weird.
The
parents are actually sort of good – Shiv Kumar and Revathy are subtly
effective, despite being stereotypical. There’s also Amrita Singh’s
stereotypical North Indian mother, and the stereotypical North Indian drunkard
father played by Ronit Roy. The latter manages to smoke everyone else out of
every single scene, mostly because he’s played the character for the third time
in a row.
Dharma’s
trademark visual style and a few moments of comedy aside, 2 States is mostly a chore and periodically infuriating. The
filmmakers had a chance to go against all odds and make a classic and they blew
it. Critical appreciation might not be the film’s target anyway, because it’s
been marketed well enough to make a truckload of money.
(First published in Firstpost)
(First published in Firstpost)